What is the government expected to announce?
The UK is expected to cut the headline target in its zero emission vehicle (ZEV) mandate from 80% of new car sales in 2030 to about 60%. The Guardian reported on 8 November that Cabinet Office minister Louise Haigh would finalise the plan after a Downing Street meeting on Wednesday. The Guardian describes Haigh as the de facto deputy prime minister.
Reuters reported the same figure on 8 November, describing a cut of about a quarter, and attributed the report to the Guardian. The BBC reported on 9 November that a significant reduction is expected, while Downing Street said no decision had been taken.
Ministers are also expected to extend the mandate's compliance flexibilities to 2034, according to the Guardian. That would soften the rule twice over: a lower headline number and more ways for manufacturers to meet it.
The cabinet has been divided. The Guardian reported that business secretary Jonathan Reynolds wanted 50%, transport secretary Heidi Alexander about 60%, and energy secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh and her predecessor Ed Miliband the current 80%. Prime Minister Andy Burnham has recused himself from the decision because his wife, Marie-France van Heel, advises the board of the Manchester charging network Be.EV, the Guardian reported. Haigh is chairing in his place.
A government spokesperson said: "The government is united in its commitment to the ZEV mandate and no decisions have been taken." The spokesperson added that the government still plans to phase out new cars that rely solely on petrol or diesel by 2030.
- •2030 headline target: expected to fall from 80% to about 60% of new car sales.
- •Flexibilities: reported extension to 2034, beyond the current 2029 limit for CO2 conversion.
- •2035 goal: 100% of new car and van sales zero emission, unchanged.
- •Timing: a Downing Street meeting on Wednesday, chaired by Louise Haigh.
What does the ZEV mandate require today?
The mandate sets a rising minimum share of zero-emission sales for each manufacturer. It is not a ban on petrol cars. Companies that fall short can buy credits, borrow allowances or pay a compliance fee.
The current car targets are 22% in 2024, 28% in 2025, 33% in 2026, 38% in 2027, 52% in 2028, 66% in 2029 and 80% in 2030, according to the Department for Transport's consultation. The government's stated goal is 100% zero-emission new car and van sales by 2035. Vans follow a separate path, from 10% in 2024 to 70% in 2030.
Compliance payments are £12,000 per car and £15,000 per van. The consultation says these are comparable to the equivalent payments in the EU. In 2024, ZEV allowances changed hands at about £4,000 each, well below the fine.
Four flexibilities do much of the work. CO2 conversion lets manufacturers that beat their emissions baseline offset part of the ZEV target until 2029. Borrowing lets them use future allowances, repaid by 2030 with 3.5% compound interest. Banking carries surplus credits forward for up to three years. Makers can also trade credits between the car and van schemes.
Pooling, trading, bonus credits and derogations for low-volume makers add further routes. The consultation says participants can comply "through both ZEV sales and the use of flexibilities". That is why a headline shortfall does not automatically mean fines.
The trajectory gets steeper from 2028. Car targets rise by 14 percentage points a year from 2028 to 2030, against an average of 5 points a year between 2024 and 2027, the consultation says. DfT modelling suggests ZEV car sales may need to grow by an average of 31% a year from 2025 to 2030 to comply.
Flexibilities have already done much of that work. In the 2024 scheme year, CO2 conversion generated the equivalent of 4.7% additional ZEV registrations for cars and 5.3% for vans. Borrowing supported about 1.2% of car compliance, and trading 2.1%. Banking set aside the equivalent of 3.7% of car registrations.
The industry exceeded the 2024 headline targets by selling electric cars and using those flexibilities, the consultation says. Final figures for the 2025 scheme year are not yet available. The 2030 date is a separate rule: new cars that rely solely on petrol or diesel cannot be sold from 2030, and hybrids can continue until 2035.
Why do carmakers say the targets are out of reach?
SMMT data for October shows 152,730 new cars registered, up 5.4% and the 11th consecutive monthly rise. Battery electric cars took 32.0% of sales that month, their highest share of the year. The year-to-date share was 26.6%, with 503,805 BEVs registered, up 30.4%.
SMMT said the October jump reflected a deliberate push to bring registrations closer to the annual target, repeating a pattern from the two previous years. Plug-in hybrids rose 30.1% to a 15.0% share, while hybrid volumes fell 5.0%.
Those figures still leave a gap. SMMT expects BEVs to reach 27.2% for 2026 against the 33% target. It forecasts 32% against 38% in 2027, and 37.5% against 52% in 2028. The shortfall would more than double by 2028 on current trends.
The industry body says makers have spent billions on discounts, low-rate finance, deposit contributions and subsidised charging to move cars. "Higher targets may force supply, but they do not create demand," SMMT said. Chief executive Mike Hawes said: "The gap between demand and mandated targets continues to widen."
SMMT sets out the stakes: £14.3bn committed to UK EV manufacturing since 2020, more than 180 BEV models on sale, an average range above 300 miles, and an £85bn automotive base supporting 188,000 jobs. It also points to a new EV-specific tax from 2028 and 20% VAT on public charging.
Fleet buying drives the market. Fleet registrations rose 5.4% to 89,985 units in October and accounted for 58.9% of all registrations, SMMT said. Private demand grew 4.1% to 58,229 units, a 38.1% share.
Public money is already in the market. The consultation says governments have committed more than £7.5bn to 2035 for chargers, EV uptake and manufacturing. The Zero Emission Van Grant has backed almost 115,000 orders since 2012, with up to £5,000 off a qualifying van.
The government has already relaxed the scheme once. Legislative changes in early 2026 extended borrowing and conversion, raised some caps and cut final compliance payments, the consultation says. The Guardian noted that ministers have diluted the targets several times since the policy was first proposed.
Demand is soft across Europe too. ACEA says battery electric cars took 22.7% of EU registrations in the first nine months of 2026, up from 16.1% a year earlier. In December 2025 the European Commission proposed softening its 2035 rule so that 90% of new cars sold would be zero emission, not 100% (BBC).
Who opposes the change?
Charging companies say weaker targets cut the demand their networks rely on. Shane Brennan, chief executive of ChargeUK, said: "Weakening the mandate puts £1.7bn of charging infrastructure at risk". He warned that investor confidence would suffer from a third change in three years.
Energy UK, the energy trade association, also opposed the move. The BBC reported that it warned lower targets could damage "the investment certainty needed to deliver the infrastructure" for the transition.
Some Labour MPs have spoken publicly. Lizzi Collinge, MP for Morecambe and Lunesdale, said the decision would have "a huge climate impact". Catherine Fookes, MP for Monmouthshire, said: "We need the ZEV mandate to stay, and Rosebank to be rejected."
Paul McNamee of the Labour Climate and Environment Forum said a significant weakening would be seen as "a rowing back on climate leadership". He called for assurances that the mandate would not be cut again and that the 2035 target would remain.
Carbon Brief's analysis puts numbers on the trade-off. It found that a 50% target, combined with heavier use of flexibilities, could mean up to 3 million fewer BEVs on UK roads by 2030. That would add £3bn a year in ownership costs, 7.4 million tonnes of CO2 in 2030 and 17 million barrels of imported oil, it estimated.
Carbon Brief also cited ECIU analysis that BEVs cost about £1,100 a year less to run than petrol cars. Transport & Environment, which opposed the EU's 2035 change, said in December 2025: "The UK must stand firm."
What would a 60% target mean for drivers?
A 60% target would lower the required share in every year from 2027. The consultation's 60% option sets 36% in 2027, 44% in 2028, 52% in 2029 and 60% in 2030. The current path is 38%, 52%, 66% and 80%.
The immediate effect is less pressure on manufacturers to buy credits or discount electric cars to hit the annual number. SMMT argues that today's discounts are unsustainable and hurt resale values. A lower target would reduce that spending.
The longer-term effect is fewer electric cars on the road. Carbon Brief estimates that means higher running costs for drivers who stay on petrol, and it warns that charging investment could suffer.
Used prices are already falling into range. The consultation cites Autotrader data showing one in four used EVs advertised at under £15,000, with the average three-to-five-year-old EV at about £18,000.
New-car support is capped by price. The £2bn Electric Car Grant, funded to 2029/30, reduces the upfront cost of EVs priced at or under £37,000. The consultation says it has supported more than 160,000 new electric car sales.
Buyers would still see more choice. SMMT counts more than 180 battery electric models on sale, with an average range above 300 miles. The 2030 ban on new petrol-only and diesel-only cars would remain, as would the 2035 zero-emission deadline.
The consultation also asks how to define the 2030 phase-out, including the treatment of hybrids. That detail will decide which models remain on sale between 2030 and 2035.
For manufacturers, the flexibility extension may matter as much as the headline cut. It would let makers lean on CO2 conversion, borrowing and banking for longer, so actual electric sales could sit below the headline number.
Hybrids do not count toward the ZEV target. A slower electric ramp would leave more room for them in the market between 2030 and 2035, when the zero-emission deadline arrives.
How does the UK compare with the EU?
The EU moved first. In December 2025 the European Commission proposed that 90% of new cars sold from 2035 would have to be zero emission, not 100%, with the rest covered by conventional cars, hybrids, e-fuels and low-carbon steel (BBC).
The consultation describes the same package as a 90% cut in tailpipe emissions. The remaining 10% could be offset with low-carbon steel made in the EU or sustainable fuels. That could leave room for plug-in hybrids, range extenders and mild hybrids after 2035, the consultation notes. The package also proposes banking and borrowing to 2032 and a lower 2030 van target, from 50% to 40%. It still needs agreement from the European Parliament and member states.
Volkswagen welcomed the change, calling it "economically sound overall". Volvo said weakening long-term commitments for short-term gain risked Europe's competitiveness. ACEA said demand was too low to avoid multi-billion-euro penalties without more flexibility.
The UK's consultation mirrors parts of that approach. It offers options of 70%, 60% and 50% for 2030, or keeping 80% with flexibilities extended to 2034. Its compliance payments are explicitly compared with EU levels.
The UK has led that group. The consultation says the UK had the largest ZEV market share of any major European market in 2024 and 2025, ahead of Germany, France and Italy.
The UK's electric share is also above the current EU average. SMMT puts the UK at 26.6% for the first 10 months of 2026, while ACEA puts the EU at 22.7% for the first nine months.
What happens next?
The decision is expected at Wednesday's Downing Street meeting, where the Guardian reports the government intends to settle the dispute. The government has not set a date for announcing the outcome.
The consultation closed on 23 October, and the government must still publish its response. The consultation says its evidence may inform future amendments to the Vehicle Emissions Trading Schemes Order, so the 2027 figure of 38% stays in force for now. The 2025 scheme year's trading window is due to open later this year.
Three dates matter after that. The 2028 EV-specific tax will test demand. The 2030 phase-out definition will decide the fate of hybrids. The 2035 zero-emission deadline remains the long-term anchor.
The charging industry will watch whether Haigh pairs the cut with new support. ChargeUK wants a stable framework and SMMT wants cheaper public charging plus long-term incentives.
The political cost will show in Labour's own ranks. MPs who back the 80% target have already warned about the climate impact, as ministers head to COP31.
